Showing posts with label localism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label localism. Show all posts

4.3.08

conversation #4

XXX: morning
me: morning
XXX: (um, right?)
me: yup
how's XXX?
XXX: yea
XXX is pretty good
felt much better today
me: I'm glad
XXX: and there were no surprise visits from my somewhat bosses
me: phew
that's always a plus
XXX: also the magical flying pirate ship i'm working on in the modeling tutorial
me: !!!
XXX: is starting to look more like a pirate ship
and less like a bad modern art sculpture
me: hahaha
oh, dude
mad modern art is the best
was it all post-cubist?
XXX: heh
oh very
me: awesome
XXX: all kinds of geometric shapes popping out where they aren't wanted
me: hehe
if you were having an especially picasso evening there'd be the odd stray horse-head
XXX: mm
yes
me: which would be wholly undesirable
XXX: rather
though this program does have an amusing feature
whereby, if i wished, i could have random teapots

all over the ship
perhaps the ship is crewed by teapots
and sails on their steam
ha ha ha
me: (I just got an email that begins:

Those gloaming hours again in which I wonder what, given its virulence and ubiquity,the plague was doing around 1400 when it could have been cutting shorter John Lydgate's infinite flow.)

Wow -- is there a teapot button?
XXX: hah wow
me: that's amazing!
XXX: yes
quite literally
a teapot button
me: I
Love
Whimsy
XXX: or even a teapot paint brush, actually
and also that is a fantastic start to an email

wow
hah
me: haha - he is reading lydgate
and not liking him much
as you can probably guess
XXX: i imagined not
heh
me: How come your status is breaking?
XXX: oh
on break
break-ing
sorry
better?

heh
me: got you
sorry I just got paid
XXX: or wait did they do those commercials in the uk?
me: and was taking a moment to be happy
yup
XXX: ooooooh
YEA for getting paid!!
me: man I love it
money is great
oh! have you read quicksilver?
XXX: nope
that's neal stephenson, right?
me: yeah
XXX: i've just started the, um, cryptonomicron
it's my first of his stuff
me: or did I already tell you about it?
ah
XXX: nope
go right ahead!
me: cryptonomicon is amazing
XXX: greatly enjoying it so far
though i wish i had bought an edition with bigger pages and font
me: quicksilver is the prequel to Cypto. It take place between 1660 and 1715
XXX: but that is neither here nor there
ooh hmm
me: or rather the trilogy of books does
XXX: (nods)
24 me: um... it's a cast, operatic, brainy, sexy, swashbuckling, incredibly researched monster ofa piece of work
*vast
XXX: wow
that sounds, um, incredibly cool
me: It includes lots of liebniz and newton
and pirates
XXX: !
so cool!!
me: and about 5 seperate heists
and Louis XIV
XXX: ...hah though i admit i had some unkind thoughts about mr. isaac newton when i started calculus
similar to your friend's in that email
whoa
....i must read this book
me: monarchs coercively having sex with other monarchs' subjects
XXX: !
as proxy or by design?
or wait
don't want to know
me: haha, calculus, oh my
No, it's not graphically unplesant
XXX: oh oh not that
me: also... pepys, and the foundation of the royal society, and of MIT
XXX: was just interested in motivation
oh!
wait
mit?1
geeesh
this guy is rapidly becoming my idol

and i haven't even finished one of his books
me: haha
I will put quicksilver in the package.
XXX: yea!!!!! (does little happy dance)
me: woop woop
I will try to include short stories and maybe poetry too if there's room in the box
XXX: hah no poetry ;-) :-p
me: do you not like poetry?
XXX: though i, um, appreciate the thought
mm
me: you lose, dude
XXX: (bows deeply)
mah
other than (weirdly) a few authors/poems who stick with me
i am not a fan of poems
me: wow - that's a sentence I could never type
XXX: hah i know
me: mind you, that's cause poems are my thing
XXX: you like the dunciad :-p
heh yes
me: and how!
XXX: i have great respect for poems and people who like them
just not my thing
me: :-)
XXX: that's actually how i encountered claude rawson
me: fair enough
XXX: trying to dodge my poetry requirement
me: oh?
ha
XXX: i had to take something with poetry more modern than milton
me: oh noes!
XXX: and ended up winning an arguement to the effect that his seminar on satire counted
as it included pope and etc.
me: that seems reasonable
XXX: it was
...i'm glad they didn't check what i wrote my papers on ;-)
me: but .... but, what about all the great 20thC american poets?
XXX: .... (sigh)
me: Lowell? Frost?Bishop? Moore? Berryman? Ashberry? Roethke? Crane?
XXX: i like some frost
out of that list
me: (author's note: I am smiling)
XXX: i also like some atwood
hah hah i thought that might be the case
also i like eliott

for whatever sadistic reason
but i think this is because he writes long poems
me: yeah, whoops that was a fairly substantial oversight on my part
XXX: i need my narrative
(laughs)
and ironically enough

my first real literary paper (pre-college, but it was the first one i everwent to crit for) was on zukofsky
me: I know zukovsky not
XXX: mmm
likely better off
very modernist
me: ha
XXX: very "ooooh eliot makes cool allusions that are impossible to understand I must do this to but make it EVEN HARDER"
but i seized on the bits that i liked
like the idea of having an image that is tied to an idea
but is not a metaphor for the idea
my poem was about a grasshopper
me: Ok, this is interesting
XXX: zukovsky?
he is interesting
me: mhm
what you are saying is interesting
XXX: oh
hah
me: bozo, what else am I going to be talking about?
XXX: (laughs)
me: (except myself, of course to which I don't usually refer as 'this')
XXX: hah ha ha ha
well you could have gotten a bonus or something...
kidding
me: It's my first month on my new pay
for that is nice
XXX: yea!
but yeah

i've tried to explain my feelings about poems to people before
i can read them
but they don't really mean much to me
me: it ok if you need narrative
XXX: the way that stories do
me: it happens
it's sad
XXX: hah
me: but for some people
you know... that's all they have

XXX: (is laughing)
me: in seriousness, I get it
because I struggle with narratives
I'm like, you want to me to do what? Analyse it? What?
XXX: yes!
exactly!

me: but how!
it's so wishy-washy!
XXX: ha ha ha
you read it and are like "okay, that was nice. ....what? I have to write a whole paper on this?!"
i love how we are having the same conversation
me: see for me poetry is just the crunchiest, most economical, most beautiful words with none o the extraneous crap about people and stuff happening to other stuff and yadda yadda
XXX: or the same feelings at least
about the opposite things
me: yes!
XXX: mm and for me narratives allow you to meet real characters, people you can learn from and encounter like actual people, and provide a looking glass and a suggested pattern for what to do with your life
...i don't have the gift of being able to describe this well

you can carry ideas to their conclusions
without unneccessarily veiling them in allusions and cryptic language
gah
(gives up)
me: no, I think I see what you mean
I just think that there's more to life than narrative would have you believe
XXX: heh
me: take closure, for example
XXX: mm
me: and I'm sorry that I haven't finished your paper yet
the weekend got in the way
XXX: ha ha aww
's okay
i hear your thesis is quite brilliant

you have to send it to me sometime :-)
me: but what happens in closure is intensely interesting and reveals the fundementally problematic nature of narrative, which is that we actually have no idea how one thing causes another, only that one thing follows another
follows, even
I think poetry is interested in those gaps

XXX: oh ho ho.... that's not a problem of narrative
that's the point!
me: where the narrative isn't
XXX: to figure out how these things happen!
me: not where the narrative isn't interested - i was unclear - I mean, where it is absent
ok, that's a fair point
XXX: exactly! that's where we come in! that's where the engagement happens!
and not just in comics
more generally
me: and whoever has been talking to you about my thesis is telling porkies!
XXX: hah
now now i thought XXX was a nice person
me: she's lovely
XXX: who certainly knows what she's talking about
me: and ((((hugs)))) on your letter
XXX: thanks (sigh)
i kinda knew it was coming

and it spurred me into action in a sense
i actually emailed u mich and harvard
me: I still kinda hoped it wasn't
oh, good on you
XXX: to be like "yo. what's going on?"
(um, in that, "thank you so much for taking the time to read my email during this busy season" kind of way)
me: yeah, of course
XXX: yeah
i dunno
i'm almost relieved in a sense
because it would have torn me to shreds to be accepted without funding
and have to deal with that
me: yes
XXX: i also agree with what many people are saying about how funding difference poisons the atmosphere of a program
because i saw that happen when i was interning
about a quarter of us were paid
the rest of us were not
me: mmmm that's interesting, but not at all the atmosphere in Berkeley
XXX: and it created a lot of bad feelings and divisions
hmm
that's good!
wow
me: XXX is sufficiently sensitive to have picked up on that, as an unfunded person
XXX: ...maybe everyone there is supernaturally nice
(nods)
oh i certainly imagine so
me: actually, because she's unfunded she gets TAships and RAships
XXX: ooooh
me: and the funded people are anxious
!
XXX: i thought that the funding, um, was entailed upon taships
me: (anxious that they're not good enough)
XXX: and that if you weren't funded then you had no shot at such things
interesting
me: some people (eg XXX) get fellowships
XXX: (nods)
me: that is what being funded is
everyone has recourse to some funding
just unfunded folks have to work for it and don't get much
XXX: ahh
huh
interesting
me: ... and have to pay tuition in the first year
XXX: ....don't really want to think about it at the moment
ah
yes
me: no no I know
sorry
XXX: there is always that
me: sorry
XXX: 's okay (sigh)
my friend lectured me today
about how i appear to be "grasping for a scattershot of programs"
me: what about?
ouch
XXX: (sigh) that is not true
this all makes sense in my head
me: ouch
XXX: i am still angry
as you can tell
me: of course it does!
well, yeah
XXX: partly because i think he's just bitter as he did an english masters
and hated it
and is still not done with said thesis
me: they clearly have no idea of you, your interests, or your applications
XXX: (firm nod)
me: ((((hugs))))
XXX: (hugs) thanks :-(
i have to remind myself
me: people are occasionally rubbisyh; there appears not to be any way around this
XXX: that things other people say are not always true
just because other people are saying them
they are

me: no! absolutely not
of course not
brb
XXX: ok
me: I have fucked up at work
will be back
sorry
XXX: oh no!
you go!
good luck!!!
(hugs)

3.3.08

on stanford

Dear XXX (and XXX),

Thanks so much for your responses, which have been really helpful and which have made me feel pretty great about Stanford. My only anxiety (or at least one of them) is that I want to live in Berkeley with my gf and commute - looking at the reqs it seems that I'll be required to take two or three classes a term, sorry, semester, sorry, quarter, and so I'd only have to drive down a couple of days a week. It looks like I'd have borrowing rights at the Bancroft too - from your experience, do you think that a setup like this would be tenable. (And from this pov it's reassuring that I'd need a car anyway.)

As far as apps go, I'd be more than happy to share my statement and sample for what they're worth. As I was saying to Ryan earlier, when people have commented personally in emails to me they have commented on my sample, not my statement, for whatever that is or isn't worth. I confess that also, not being in the system in any sense as an international student whose recommenders knew no-one, I insidiated myself with the faculty at colleges I really liked. I'm in the incredibly lucky position of having supportive parents, and they helped me out with visiting colleges I liked and meeting up with professors I wanted to work with. I emailed them all two months in advance, give or take. I bound up copies of my Master's dissertation and distributed them liberally, which I just hated doing because self-promotion is for scummy right-wing politicians, but which I think was probably worthwhile. Certainly, I've had a better strike rate, if I can be crass about it, at schools where I met people then I have where I didn't. But I'd definitely be more than happy to offer any and all help you wanted, if I can offer it without sounding like an arse.

I'm also pumped by the awesome things you say about XXX XXX, who basically seems to be the Bomb in human form. One thing I was wondering, though – what are the possibilities for interdisciplinary study? I would love to take a couple classes in Urban Studies or in theories of space, for example – would I be able to do that, do you know? The interdisciplinarity is something that I actually preferred about Berkeley, where it is actually a requirement to have someone from another department on your doctoral committee. Also at Berk there are a couple of Stanford grad students who have cross-registered in Berk classes – is this something that's done much?

Thanks also for all the tips about where's good to go in Palo Alto – my question is also whether there are any shit-hot bookshops in PA?

I'm also at work, and also bored by it. My report on Danish sub-regional financial autonomy just isn't getting written…

xxx

11.2.08

constitutional localism

Dear XXX,
Thanks very much for your email and my sincere apologies for not having got back to you and the lack of specificity. And I'm grateful for your response nonetheless.
In terms of the countries on which we'd like to focus, We would like choose Denmark, France, Germany and the Netherland, and Australia, NZ, S.A. and Canada. We feel that anything more would be beyond our scope. We sent more detailed outline of our project to XXX XXX, which I enclose herewith too. We've started work on the first section, dealing with Charter compliance.
I also enclose the email I sent XXX. You'll notice that in my email to him I also mentioned that we will need funding in order to complete the project: I explain why below, but it's worth restating the reasons why we do:
- We are extremely excited about this project and look forward to bringing it to a successful completion and launching the report to our mutual benefit
- Nonetheless, as the project needs to be written during February and early March, it necessarily requires our very small team to take time out of what has been traditionally our recruitment season, during which we hope to find new members to fund XXX for the following year. Recruiting new members immediately after the start of the new financial year has historically been very unpromising proposition.
- Owing to this, unfortunately we need to ask the XXX to compensate us for the opportunity cost that this time spent represents.
- We very much hope that this won't be an obstacle to our continuing to work on this project, which we both feel is highly promising and about which we are both very optimistic.
The perspective of the report is that we believe that local government has greater freedoms in the peer group that we isolate and that it is worth analysing the ways in which local government is especially hampered in England and highlighting them by contrast to international, more liberalised practice. I will accordingly run through the questions you ask of each topic, with apologies for repetition of material in my email to XXX below or in the enclosed proposed project structure. I want also to emphasis that the five areas I asked you to get back to me on didn't reflect a full structural proposal.
1. A comparative analysis on which services are delivered locally: I think that an exhaustive examination of services is beyond the scope of the report. We should probably confine ourselves to mechanisms of delivery for health, education and transport funding. The CLGF handbook is, as you say, exemplary in this regard. A similar breakdown on the four European peers would be great.

2. Performance management regimes in commonwealth and EU countries: As you say, this is too broad a title. You're also right that a comparison of the CPA/CAA/PSA regimes with others is what we want, but we're also loking to highlight the fact that abroad performance management as it is understood here doesn't really exist - abroad authorities abroad are more monitored for illegality than for poor performance, as far as I understand it. Something that we would like to conclude from this would be that a lighter regulatory touch (as opposed to the CPA's mere 200 indicators) makes for a more innovative and effective council.

3. Local government role if any in the legislatures: We want to know whether councillors have legislative roles in the targetted peer group partly because it is something that XXX XXX mentioned in his inaugural speech. We know that it is a rather unrealistic thing to agitate for, and that accordingly too great a concentration on it would dilute the persuasiveness of the report, but we think that as a long-term ambition for local government it would help to compensate a fairly substantial democratic deficit. So yes, we are " looking to find out where local councillors are represented in the lower and upper houses" as you say. This isn't a core analytical point - it's a prospective goal. If such an analysis could reveal that subsidiarity was better achieved with the inclusion of councillors in the legislature then it would, of course, be a useful thing to include and would bolster the profile of this section in the report.

4. Status or protection in written constitution:

5. Scope for reorganisation - who can do it and how? Points four and five I now realise really address the same point from different angles. You ask whether the fifth question should read "devolution of powers and how to achieve it" but that is in fact the converse perspective to what I had intended, which was rather a comparative examination of the ease of difficulty with which central governments can erode, curb or curtail local autonomy. While we are interested in how devolution can be achieved, some countries have strong safegaurds on their local governments' autonomy: for example Denmark (I think) requires that constitutional changes to local gov't status must be passed by two successive legislatures by two-thirds majorities. Of course, no such protection exists here, but to avoid this section becoming a constitutionalist's screed we would also like to focus on how fresh legislation in a selection of our peer countries (all of them would be too many) allocated resources and powers to local authorities. On what terms are new powers meted out - is there a set mechanism which determines the different levels to which the responsibility for administering new funding or legislation is given? "I have some extensive info on Denmark which has undergone a major transformation of local government in 2006 (reducing the number of councils, and then giving them more powers including welfare etc – very good info which I will send you). Are you also looking for info on where the relationship between central / local is better? " This sounds exactly right - yes please. For this more in-depth part of the report, I think we'd want to focus on Denmark and Germany.

I know that XXX is also interested in consitutional safeguards of local government status from the perspective of counties and districts bidding for unitary status: if we could see the relevant clauses of countries' consitutions which refer to the circumstances under which authority reorganisation can be undertaken - if such clauses or guidelines exist.

I hope that you find this a useful set of responses. We are of course flexible as to when you supply the information - we don't have to write the report linearly. We would, however, like to be able to publish by mid- to late March if possible. We also look forward to taking this forward with you and I look forward to hearing back from you. Please find below my earlier email to XXX.

With all best wishes,

XXX

31.1.08

Social care

Secondly, as I say, I’ve looked through the Wanless Social Care Review, Securing Good Care for Older People: Taking a long-term view.

Basic points are as follows: Social care is a growth industry, with funding to maintain outcomes increasing by 139% from 2002 to 2026 alone. The aging demography of the UK is well known, and the problem is compounded by the fact that a significant proportion of informal care is delivered by the elderly themselves (one in six people over 65 delivers informal social care).

Wanless’ remit is to improve outcomes as much as possible and as efficiently as possible against a benchmark which boils down to one year of substantially improved care at 20000 pounds’ worth of expenditure per head. The three models that Wanless sets out are: partnership, (two-thirds of the benchmark cost is met by the state, then individuals make contributions which are matched 1:1 up the benchmark limit, beyond which contributions are not matched. Means-tested Benefits for those unable to contribute), free personal care, (state meets whole benchmark, no personal contribution) and limited liability (hybrid, means tested provision for the first 3 or 4 years, thereafter free).

Regardless of the philosophical arguments around free provision, it seems to me that in his summary, Wanless finds evidence over and again in support of a Partnership-based funding model for social care in the future, though in his conclusion he equivocates a little and dilutes the strong case that he has built. Wanless uses a range of economic criteria to reach this conclusion (p.xxxiii or the summary).

There is a strong localist case to be made for partnership allocation of funding, based primarly upon the complexity of the means-testing, which (under partnership would not include housing value) and on the differing allocations to be made: factors include housing, domestic support, personal care, nursing care. Because means-testing would take into account other benefits administered, the case for a locally-administered partnership funding model for social care is the same as every other argument for localist solutions (ie, that the principle of subsidiarity is inarguable), only, because of the complexity of the assessments to be made, more so.

At this point, it is instructive to look at the figures involved. Under Wanless’ suggestions (and I am taking his baseline most conservative estimate that delivers zero improvements in outcomes, but which simply restructures funding models), by 2026 costs are projected to be 24bn. With improvements in service delivery, that figure jumps to 31.3bn. This is against the background of current figures of 10.1bn.

It is worth putting these numbers into some context: Alan Johnson has just conceded that Individual budgets are going to go ahead, and to do this has released 520m. For local government to have any kind of angle in future social care provision, let’s say that it would need administration over only 50% of funding: this means that central government would have needed to sign a social care concordat handing over 5.05bn to local authorities four years ago. Alan Johnson’s commitment in December is one tenth of this.

My point is that to agitate for a localist delivery of social care is not a politically realistic thing to do. We might be able to get funding from, say, XXX, were we to write a report calling for complete local control of social care, but who would take seriously a report demanding the 12bn handover necessary to meet social care costs in 2008, dwarfing by 24 times Alan Johnson’s grand gesture? On the other hand, whilst I don’t doubt that we could put together a report which strongly advocating the partnership model and its localist implementation, I don’t think that, given the practical obstacles, a report like that would get funded. After all, we know that partnership-funded care is best because it’s there in the Wanless report already.

The problems in my argument are that the King’s Fund might have had its own agenda in putting these figures together and so there might be inaccuracies, and that the report itself dates from 2006 and so might be out of date.

The point of all this is that I was wondering whether you could set down for me a brief abstract of the angle that you think that we could viably take in such a report. If you could send me one then we’d be able to build on it start putting together a position and a proposal from there.