Showing posts with label depression. Show all posts
Showing posts with label depression. Show all posts

3.3.08

on depression

XXX finally joined FB, so I messaged him your post to get his highly qualified opinion (he's currently chief resident of psychiatry at XXX General Hospital).

Here goes:

Out of the erudite arguments of the post, I emphasise two things:
1) "we don't know what depression is..."

Depression is an overdetermined, multifactorial illness. There are probably a hundred different pathophysiologic conditions that are lumped together under the name depression. Kind of like how for what we call snow, the Eskimos have many more words. So it makes sense that any treatment for "depression" will treat only a limited percentage of users, and that the data for its efficacy will be controversial and mixed. I have seen antidepressants fail miserably. I've also seen them, and other related meds, literally wake people from the dead. I understand that human beings, and their biopsychosocial illnesses, defy any simple explanation or treatment.

2) Treating a psychological condition with medication is also one way of ascribing "meaning" to the condition. It medicalizes the condition; it pharmacologizes it. As you mentioned, it quantifies it on a scale of milligrams of drug. For many, having a medication validates that they are truly suffering--and that seems to be a response to a societal indifference to suffering we are all occasionally guilty of, whether you attribute it to the breakdown of the extended family, or breakdown of the tight-knit local community, or our generation of "narcissism combined with nihilism" as Al Gore put it. Depression is at its base a loss of hope--and meaning is the antidote to hopelessness. Sometimes a pill is both meaningful, and efficacious...

26.2.08

the still sad music of humanity

The whole point of crying is to stop before you corny it up.
(Richard Yates, Revolutionary Road)

The publication in 1994 of Listening to Prozac by Peter Kramer, in which he suggested anyone with too little "joy juice" might give themselves a dose of the "mood brightener" Prozac , lifted sales into the stratosphere. (Independent, 26/2/08)

Today, a major new study shows that Prozac, taken by 40 million people worldwide, does not work and nor do similar types of drugs. For a profession normally diplomatic, the words today of one of study's authors are damning. "Given these results", Professor Kirsch of Hull University says, "there seems little reason to prescribe antidepressant medication to any but the most severely depressed patients." (Guardian, 26/2/08)
The problem with depression is that people are generally disinclined to believe that it exists. Not that people disbelieve melancholy. Chaucer believed in it, and so did Durer. But they disbelieve, instead, that depression could be a condition worthy of medical attention. Never mind that an excess of melancholy was treated by emetics and blood-letting, before they got the circulatory system was figured out. The problem is that, having stopped treating it because the grounds for treatment were found to be faulty, which is fair enough, the treatment itself resurged because the condition was still endemic. Whether it's electroshock therapy, or some kind of analysis, or cognitive behavioural therapy, or anti-depressants, the past hundred years have (I guess) a pretty consistent theme of reworking and treating the Black Knight's complaint, assuaging his unhappiness as the dream is unable to do.

What I'm getting at is this: irrespective of whether anti-depressants work, or of whether blood-letting and leeches worked; we have been turning to doctors, asking for treatment for a pain we can't place but which saps the very life out of us for as long as there have been doctors.

Maybe anti-depressants don't 'work', however that functionality is calibrated. Maybe no anti-depressant treatment has truly 'worked' - for example, exercise is just a stimulated deferral - but perhaps it's more telling that we feel compelled to be treated. So what if the pills are placebos? To all intents and purposes I find it impossible to distinguish between a psychological medicine that works because it works, and one that works because you think it works. Any takers for that one?

I don't really mind if my antidepressants are placebos. And I am as hostile to Big Pharma as anyone else. It seems to me that antidepressants are just a heavily industrialised extension of an old solution to an old, old phenomenon: that we need institutions (and the very institution in particular that is the guardian and guarantor of our health) to recognise that we have interiority. Paradoxically, maybe we need an institutional recognition that there is something about consciousness that is indivisible?

In a way, that the latest treatment for depression is unmasked as a kind of quackery isn't a victory for the scientist who've produced this report, or the anti-Pharma activists, or for the people who say that depression is a self-constructing, self-perpetuating phenomenon. This is because we don't really know what depression is, beyond an ever more minute catalogue of its symptoms. We don't really know how to cure it, either. And we certainly don't know why it is that we keep taking cures that, though they work, demonstrably don't work. (Phrenology, anyone?)

it seems that there's a blind-leading-the-blind element here. Scientists devise fake treatments that work for a non-existent condition that is described by one analyst and philosopher as 'like death-in-life'. Other scientists then expose these treatments as bogus (although they too are wrong). New treatments are designed simply to meet demand. Lather, rinse, repeat.

We don't know what our antic disposition is (or why so many accounts of depression sound a lot like Hamlet's 'seeming' rather than 'being') but soon there'll be another cure for it. People will re-engineer SSRIs, perhaps, but there'll be something else, something new. It'll be wonderfully effective, too - it'll be the new wonder treatment for depression, until we figure out that in fact, it doesn't work at all. All this makes me think of that wonderful Simon Armitage poem, To his Lost Lover;

Now they are no longer
any trouble to each other

he can turn things over, get down to that list
of things that never happened, all of the lost

unfinishable business.
For instance… for instance,

how he never clipped and kept her hair, or drew a hairbrush
through that style of hers, and never knew how not to blush

at the fall of her name in close company.
How they never slept like buried cutlery –

two spoons or forks cupped perfectly together,
or made the most of some heavy weather –

walked out into hard rain under sheet lightning,
or did the gears while the other was driving.

How he never raised his fingertips
to stop the segments of her lips

from breaking the news,
or tasted the fruit

or picked for himself the pear of her heart,
or lifted her hand to where his own heart

was a small, dark, terrified bird
in her grip. Where it hurt.

Or said the right thing,
or put it in writing.

And never fled the black mile back to his house
before midnight, or coaxed another button of her blouse,

the another,
or knew her

favourite colour,
her taste, her flavour,

and never ran a bath or held a towel for her,
or soft-soaped her, or whipped her hair

into an ice-cream cornet or a beehive
of lather, or acted out of turn, or misbehaved

when he might have, or worked a comb
where no comb had been, or walked back home

through a black mile hugging a punctured heart,
where it hurt, where it hurt, or helped her hand

to his butterfly heart
in its two blue halves.

And never almost cried,
and never once described

an attack of the heart,
or under a silk shirt

nursed in his hand her breast,
her left, like a tear of flesh

wept by the heart,
where it hurts,

or brushed with his thumb the nut of her nipple,
or drank intoxicating liquors from her navel.

Or christened the Pole Star in her name,
or shielded the mask of her face like a flame,

a pilot light,
or stayed the night,

or steered her back to that house of his,
or said “Don’t ask me how it is

I like you.
I just might do.”

How he never figured out a fireproof plan,
or unravelled her hand, as if her hand

were a solid ball
of silver foil

and discovered a lifeline hiding inside it,
and measured the trace of his own alongside it.

But said some things and never meant them –
sweet nothings anybody could have mentioned.

And left unsaid some things he should have spoken,
about the heart, where it hurt exactly, and how often.


nighttime habits.

Apparently, I wake her up - but not myself - crying about one night in three. I have no idea what about. The last time I shared a room with my dad I woke him up - but not myself - saying over and again "I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry".

14.2.08

"Update"

I am, I think, happier than I can remember being for a long, long time. I don't want to gloat so as to cause anyone upset, but - I really feel like things have turned a corner for me.

At the end of March I am moving out to California to go and live with XXX. She is just extraordinary - constantly surprising and challenging and with eerie emotional and mental synchronies and I am very, very much in love with her. I will stay until my tourist visa runs out, just before my birthday in June.I applied to grad schools again - fifteen of them! - and I have heard back from UCLA, who rejected me, and Duke, who want to admit me with a full tuition waiver, a $19kpa stipend for 6 years and a 4 year Uniersity-wide fellowship, the James B. Duke fellowship. When I got the email I cried like a baby and called up the next day to check they hadn't made a mistake. They hadn't. At least, not an administrative one! I'm still waiting on Stanford, Berkeley (and those two are my top two choices for obvious reasons), Columbia, NYU, Penn, Harvard, Yale, UVa, JHU, WashU STL, UChicago, UMich and Rutgers. Come what may, though, it's finally going to happen, whereever it happens - I'm going to graduate school! I just can't believe it.

At the end of last june - on my birthday, in fact - I went to the doctor, which was something I had been putting off for some years, and told him that I had been told that had symptoms of anxiety and depression. He diagnosed me as severe and gave me a prescription and we argued about it - he gave me something like 6 hours in four days - and I told him I felt like he'd pathologised my personality and then medicated it, and he countered that that was because I'd confused my feelings with my personality and that that was something that he wanted to stop. Since starting to take them I have stopped hitting irrational rages and thumping walls, stopped systematically alienating people who try to help me, stopped having that horrible, horrible ballooning terror and dread of everything all the time, the crippling social anxiety, the reflexive spite and bile and meanness - gone. I don't feel chemical, or artificial, or messed-with, or like I'm living through felt. I feel - fine. (I just get drunk really, really quickly.)

My job is fine. I got another pay rise and handed in my notice at the same time, which was gratifying. I am advertising my room, and starting to pack up my things. Living in London is difficult and has driven me to tears of frustration every now and then, but on balance I am so glad to have had this six months working in Westminster, learning about politics. I've put in to do a freelance political research job while I'm in CA, which will be great - hoping it comes through!I've been too coy with this blog for too long. I'm going to try to be a bit more honest and have a bit less silly over-determined angst. We'll see how it goes. I hope that you are all doing ok. Much love and a happy valentine's day to you all-

13.2.08

Enid Roach

I have, however, found the time to read a novel. Patrick Hamilton's The Slaves of Solitude. It is extraordinary bleak - reading it is like being broken over someone's knee like a tiny piece of kindling. Any novel in which the heroine's first name is not revealed until 160 pages in - and you don't even notice - is doing something right. It chronicles the relentless self-sabotage of a woman walling herself slowly into loneliness, spinsterhood, penury and, possibly death. I've never read such an utterly forceful account of the sheer insidious poison of self-doubt, and pessimism, and self-imposed victimhood.

11.2.08

therapy #2

ROS: Six rhetorical and two repetitions, leaving nineteen of which we answered fifteen. And what did we get in return? He's depressed!... Denmark's a prison and he'd rather live in a nutshell; some shadow-play about the nature of ambition, which never got down to cases, and finally one direct question which might have led somewhere, and led in fact to his illuminating claim to tell a hawk from a handsaw.